Peer Review Guidelines

SUSTAINABLE CAMPUS (peer review)
Essay #3
Due: 10/21 (bring 2 printed copies)

1. What parts of the essay do you find most convincing and why?
2. What parts are still unclear or feel incomplete? 
3. Identify and rephrase the central claim of the paper. 
4. Does it say something not obvious and significant about the "artifact"? 
5. List and comment on the major points and evidence used to support the central claim. 
6. How and when have potential counter-arguments been addressed? Suggest some of your own. 
7. Indicate sentences or paragraphs that seem out of order, or in need of revision.